For Auction

Receivership Sale | 97% Occupied Kroger-Anchored Shopping Center

5173 W Washington Street,
Indianapolis, IN 46241

Asset Snapshot

Real Estate
Asset Type
Retail
Property Type
Grocery Anchored Center
Retail Subtype
97%
Occupancy
Yes
Anchor
Kroger
Anchor Tenant(s)

Offering Summary

Property Highlights: 

  • Kroger Anchor: 74% of GLA, 60% Income: Long-standing operator generates 877K annual visits, in the top 25% of the chain on visits per SF.
  • 97% Occupied with 6 National Brand Tenants: Roster includes Papa John's, H&R Block, and Humana CenterWell across 94% of leased GLA.
  • New 7-Year Humana CenterWell NNN Lease: Senior Primary Care provider at $16/SF brings consistent medical foot traffic to the center.
  • 550 Ft Frontage on 20,700 VPD Corridor: Signalized entry on W. Washington Street arterial linking Downtown Indianapolis to I-465.
  • 100% NNN Leases: 91.4% Expense Recovery: Tenant-paid taxes, insurance, and CAM deliver predictable cash flow with minimal landlord burden.
  • 13.4% MSA Population Growth Since 2010: Densely populated Indianapolis trade area with a 1,900 SF vacancy providing lease-up upside.


Offering Summary:

Marcus & Millichap, in partnership with RealINSIGHT Marketplace, is pleased to present Westgate Plaza, a 66,469 SF grocery-anchored community shopping center in the heart of Indianapolis, Indiana. The Property is 97% occupied and anchored by a long-standing Kroger that occupies 74% of GLA, contributes 60% of gross income, and generates approximately 877,000 annual customer visits, ranking in the top 25% nationally on a visits-per-SF basis. The Kroger fuel outparcel and drive-thru pharmacy enhance customer draw, while a newly signed 7-year lease with Humana CenterWell Senior Primary Care at $16/SF NNN adds a strong medical traffic component. Five long-standing small-shop tenants, including Papa John's and H&R Block, contribute stable, recurring income, and 6 of 7 tenants occupying 94% of GLA are national brands. All tenants are on NNN leases with 91.4% recovery of landlord expenses, delivering operational efficiency and upside through the lease-up of a 1,900 SF vacancy. Strategically located 0.8 miles from I-465 along the high-traffic W. Washington Street corridor (20,700 VPD) with 550 feet of frontage and a signalized entrance, the Property sits in a densely populated trade area within an Indianapolis MSA that has grown 13.4% since 2010. Priced well below replacement cost, Westgate Plaza is positioned for durable cash flow and long-term value creation.


Location:

Westgate Plaza fronts 550 feet along W. Washington Street (20,700 VPD), the primary east-west arterial connecting Downtown Indianapolis with I-465 just 0.8 miles to the west. The signalized entry, Kroger fuel outparcel, and drive-thru pharmacy anchor a densely populated trade area, with major national retailers nearby in a fast-growing Indianapolis MSA up 13.4% since 2010.
  • 0.8 mi Distance to I-465 interchange
  • 20,700 Vehicles per day on W. Washington St
  • 13.4% Indy MSA population growth since 2010

Due Diligence

Transaction Managers

Platform Fee

Buyer pays a minimum platform fee of 5% or $25,000 at closing.

How it Works

Learn about bidding, reserve prices, and closing.

Read the auction guide

Auctioneer

Bryan P. Jackson
c/o Fisher Auction Company Inc.
License: AU09100175

Need Help?

Your transaction managers are your first point of contact for any auction or process questions. For additional support:

Under Contract

This asset was part of the July 15th, 2026 auction event and is currently under contract.
Ready to sell your asset on the platform with the highest trade rate in the industry?
Interested in additional investment opportunities?

Investment Sales Brokers

Craig Fuller
Marcus & Millichap
Julia Evinger
Marcus & Millichap
IN License: RB14040143

Disclaimers

The information being provided herein is for informational purposes only. No representation or warranty is made as to the accuracy or completeness of any information contained herein, including, without limitation, any information regarding the condition of the Property, the condition of title or Property descriptions. Any documents and/or pictures posted herein or elsewhere on the RealINSIGHT Marketplace (the "Website") are for informational purposes only, and may not represent the current condition of the Property or the condition of the Property at the time of sale. The posting of pictures herein or elsewhere on the Website does not constitute a guarantee that any items represented in the pictures will be present when the buyer takes possession of the Property. You are encouraged to conduct your own due diligence and investigate all matters relating to the Property. It is recommended that you seek independent advice, including legal advice, to perform your due diligence and that you use good faith efforts in determining that the content of all information provided to or obtained by you is accurate.